Listen to "Reality Check with Ben Swann" on Spreaker.

Judge rules you cannot sue the NSA for secretly spying on you unless you can prove they are secretly spying on you

Must Read

Pentagon’s “COVID Detecting Microchip” For Under Your Skin?

Pentagon's "COVID Detecting Microchip" For Under Your Skin? - powered by ise.media A new report from 60 Minutes includes an...

Life Insurance Unchanged By COVID?

Life Insurance Unchanged By COVID? - powered by ise.media Bob Burnett explains how life insurance rates are telling a very...

Nicaragua Never Required Masks or Lockdowns and Crushed the Virus-Script

Nicaragua Never Required Masks or Lockdowns and Crushed the Virus-Script - powered by ise.media The country of Nicaragua never instituted...
Zach McAuliffe
Zach McAuliffe is a University of Dayton alumni with degrees in journalism and English. He wants to present people with all the facts they need to make informed decisions on the world around them. He also enjoys Shakespeare and long walks on the beach with his puppy Lily.

A California district judge ruled on Tuesday U.S. citizens cannot sue the National Security Agency for invading their privacy covertly unless the citizen can prove, without a doubt, the NSA was spying secretly on the citizen.

District Judge Jeffrey White ruled in Jewel v. NSA, the plaintiff could not sue the NSA because they did not obtain and provide for the courts any evidence showing their personal information was collected by the agency. Because of Jewel’s failure to provide such information, White wrote, according to Mother Jones, “even if Plaintiffs could establish standing, a potential Fourth Amendment Claim would have to be dismissed on the basis that any possible defenses would require impermissible disclosure of state secret information.”

What this means is even though the NSA has said in the past they are responsible for spying on American citizens, the NSA has not disclosed exactly how they spy on citizens. Because they have not disclosed the extent to which, or even how, they spy on citizens, it is therefore illegal to sue them for an invasion of privacy. However, once the methods are known, which the NSA has kept secret under the premise of national security, then citizens will be able to sue the NSA for an invasion of privacy.

- Newsletter -

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, who represented the plaintiff in court, released a statement after the ruling, which reads the “ruling in Jewel v. NSA was not a declaration that NSA spying is legal. The judge decided instead that ‘state secrets’ prevented him from ruling whether the program is constitutional.”

The full court ruling can be found here.

The EFF has also said they will continue to fight to bring an end to the mass surveillance or citizen’s data despite this ruling.

- Advertisement -

Featrued Sponsors

video

Texas Files Lawsuit Asks SCOTUS To Block 4 States From Participating in Electoral College

Texas Files Lawsuit Asks SCOTUS To Block 4 States From Participating in Electoral College - powered by ise.media Check out our sponsor Kim Daly and...

Unstoppable Domains

Uncensorable blockchain domains. Every domain purchase supports Ben Swann and Truth in Media

Holland Center

Holland Center is a day treatment program and medical clinic for children with autism.
- Advertisement -

Latest News

video

Pentagon’s “COVID Detecting Microchip” For Under Your Skin?

Pentagon's "COVID Detecting Microchip" For Under Your Skin? - powered by ise.media A new report from 60 Minutes includes an...
video

Life Insurance Unchanged By COVID?

Life Insurance Unchanged By COVID? - powered by ise.media Bob Burnett explains how life insurance rates are telling a very different story about the COVID...
video

Nicaragua Never Required Masks or Lockdowns and Crushed the Virus-Script

Nicaragua Never Required Masks or Lockdowns and Crushed the Virus-Script - powered by ise.media The country of Nicaragua never instituted a lockdown, never required masks,...
video

Report: 80% of Women /Girls From Mexico To US, Raped Along The Way

Report: 80% of Women /Girls From Mexico To US, Raped Along The Way - powered by ise.media The crisis at the U.S. border continues. Nearly...
video

Lockdowns Caused 100 Percent Increase In Child and Teen Suicide?

Lockdowns Caused 100 Percent Increase In Child and Teen Suicide? - powered by ise.media Children are 10 times more likely to die of suicide than...
- Advertisement -

More Articles Like This